Determinants of delayed recovery of consciousness in the ICU in severe COVID-19

Determinants of delayed recovery of consciousness after analgosedation discontinuation in the intensive care unit: insights from patients with COVID-19 hypoxemic respiratory failure

Seyed A. Safavynia, Megan E. Barra, Caroline Der Nigoghossian, Daniel Shinnick, Greer Waldrop, Jacky M. Choi, Wolfgang Ganglberger, Qi Shen, Kevin Doyle, Maria C. Walline, M. Brandon Westover, Emery N. Brown, Joseph J Fins, Jonathan Victor, Brian L. Edlow, Jan Claassen, Nicholas D. Schiff, and Tanayott Thaweethai

Critical Care Medicine, accepted (2026)

Abstract

Objective: Prolonged disorders of consciousness are common in critically-ill patients receiving mechanical ventilation, and often attributed to prolonged sedative exposure in the setting of decreased drug clearance and/or reduced metabolism. Here in a large sample of critically-ill COVID patients obtained over a short period, we tested the assumption that prolonged unconsciousness following benzodiazepine and/or propofol sedation can be attributed to residual exposure. Further, we examine associations between clinical variables on time to recovery of consciousness (RoC) as a framework for the broader critically-ill population.

Design: Retrospective cohort study.

Setting: Massachusetts General Hospital, Weill Cornell Medicine, Columbia University Irving Medical Center. Patients: Seven hundred eighty-four patients with COVID-19 critical illness in Spring–Summer 2020.

Interventions: None.

Measurements and Main Results: We estimated the latest expected recovery of consciousness (LERoC) using models of sedation exposure that account for sedativespecific pharmacokinetics and critical illness. Our primary exposure variable was a time-weighted dose of analgosedative agents at benzodiazepine and/or propofol cessation; our primary outcome was time to RoC. We estimated relative risks for late RoC (i.e., after LERoC) via multinomial logistic regression. Among individuals with late RoC, we fit a multivariate subdistribution hazard model for time to RoC. 73% of patients had RoC before hospital discharge, yet 34% of patients achieving RoC did not do so within pharmacologically plausible sedative elimination times. Patients with late RoC were older and exhibited hypoxemia and acute kidney injury. Patients with dexmedetomidine as an adjunct sedative had a disproportionately larger incidence of early recovery. Patients with early versus late RoC did not have significantly different discharge dispositions.

Conclusions: In our cohort, the time to RoC was commonly prolonged beyond that expected from sedation exposures alone. These data may aid clinicians and families with expectations of RoC and warrant investigation of alternative determinants of delayed RoC in this population.


Download a preprint and supplement
Related publication: the protected down-regulated state
Related publication: hypoxia and late recovery of consciousness in COVID-19
Related publication: late recovery of consciousness in COVID-19
Related publication: review of pathophysiology and recovery mechanisms in disorders of consciousness
Related publication: prolonged recovery following anoxic brain
Publications related to consciousness and brain dynamics
Return to publications list